Kevin O'Toole
NYC
LB
Balanced Full Back
Dec 14, 1998 (27)
Left
5'10"
150 lb
New York CityReturns in Leagues Cup
O'Toole (groin) played the first half of Thursday's 2-0 Leagues Cup win over Santos Laguna, confirming he is recovered from injury.
Analysis: O'Toole had been progressing well in his recovery from May groin surgery, recently returning to full training after being described as ticking all the boxes. His appearance in this match now confirms that recovery process is complete, positioning him to regain his starting role at either left back or in the midfield like he played against the Mexican club.
Back in full training
O'Toole (groin) is back in full training, according to Glenn Crooks.
Analysis: O'Toole had been progressing well in his recovery from May groin surgery, recently described as ticking all the boxes before this full return to training. His energy and attacking output from left back give the squad added depth once he's fully reintegrated, with Nicholas Cavallo having started in his place during his recovery. O'Toole is expected to be reintegrated into the squad in the coming days.
Remains out Friday
O'Toole (groin) remains out for Friday's game against Toronto FC, according to the club.
Analysis: O'Toole had been progressing well in his recovery from May groin surgery, recently described as ticking all the boxes in training and appearing poised for a return. Despite that encouraging buildup, he will not be available this time around, with Nicholas Cavallo set to start in his place at left back, and his path back into the starting lineup will be worth monitoring as New York City FC continues to manage his reintegration.
Could make squad Friday
O'Toole (groin) could return to the squad for Friday's game against Toronto FC after "ticking all the boxes" in training this week, manager Pascal Jansen told New York Soccer Journal on Wednesday.
Analysis: O'Toole underwent groin surgery in May but has been progressing well in his rehab, to the point that he could return to the squad this weekend. When healthy, the left-back has been a regular starter for NYCFC, as evidenced by the fact that he's started the 10 MLS matches he's been available for this season. Barring any late setbacks, O'Toole looks poised to return to the squad this Friday.
Set to return to team sessions
O'Toole (groin) is set to return to team training sessions in one to two weeks, according to the NY Soccer Journal.
Analysis: O'Toole underwent groin surgery in May and recently signed a contract extension with New York City FC through the 2028/29 season, with an option for an additional year. He has been a regular starter for the club when healthy, making at least 27 starts in each of the last two MLS seasons, and his upcoming return to team training marks a positive step toward reclaiming his spot at left back once he works his way back to full match fitness.
Signs contract extension
O'Toole (groin) signed a contract extension with New York City FC until the end of the 2028/29 MLS season, the club announced Thursday. The deal also includes an option for 2029/30.
Analysis: O'Toole underwent groin surgery in May, and it's uncertain when he'll be able to return to action, but the left-back has been a regular starter for NYCFC when healthy. He's made at least 27 starts in each of the last two MLS seasons, and he's expected to recover the starting nod on the left side of the defense once he's ready to return to action.
Ruled out after surgery
O'Toole is sidelined for the time being following a procedure on his groin and abdomen, according to his club.
Analysis: O'Toole won't play at least until after the World Cup break while the exact severity of his problems remains unclear. The left-back was initially a consistent starter, and losing him hurts the team both defensively and offensively on the flank. He has already been absent since April 25, with Nicholas Cavallo absorbing his playing time.
Sidelined with leg injury
O'Toole is dealing with a leg injury that makes him unavailable for the time being.
Analysis: O'Toole's has played all minutes in every MLS match this year, so losing him is a huge blow to the team. Nicholas Cavallo could take his place in the starting lineup for the duration of his recovery process. While the full extent of O'Toole's issue is uncertain, he should be expected to regain a major role as soon as he's healthy.
Select Player
Search and select a player to compare