Aiden O'Neill

Analysis: O'Neill missed seven MLS games due to his rehabilitation from ankle surgery after returning from his participation at the World Cup, where he had featured four times for the Australian national team. The midfielder is now in contention, though it might take a few more weeks for him to regain a starting role from either James Sands or Andres Perea. Prior to the issue, O'Neill was averaging 51.0 accurate passes, 5.2 duels won and 2.6 tackles per game in the 2026 MLS season.

Jul 20, 2026

Undergoes successful ankle surgery

O'Neill underwent successful surgery on his left ankle this past Monday and has begun his rehab, with estimated recovery period around four to six week timeline, according to the club.

Analysis: O'Neill has made 11 appearances with three assists in MLS this season, and the injury comes after he helped Australia reach the round of 32 at the World Cup, where he was named Player of the Match against Paraguay. O'Neill has been an undisputed starter in the engine room for NYCFC and his absence will allow Andres Perea to see more playing time in the coming weeks.